21 October 2007

tagged: a tail of words


Do you know what good writing is? For that matter, do you know what good soup is? Or good art? Okay, how about a good song? Why call a beer good? Now that we are on the topic, what exactly is a good girl? Do you know any? Could you forward me their numbers when you are done reading this?

I have been tagged by Gaizabonts to shed some light, my light, on the subject: "strengths of a writer". The Writer's Meme, its called. And though this is a better tag, far better than the "spot the 18 lies about my homophobic uncle turned miniature taxidermist" kinds, it is also kind of pressurising.

But more relevant. Because as bloggers we write and share our lives, likes, dislikes, quirks with millions of nameless stumblers. And we try our best to make it as readable and interesting as possible. We proclaim, educate, amuse, impress and ocassionally seduce (yes, yes, yes). So it is but natural, that most of us will have sound and somewhat vociferous ideas of what makes the cut. And like all opinions, you might not agree with a few. But that's ok. We still have regular jobs. And working plastic.

So here I go. In my attempt to try and encapsulate all that I know about the myriad strengths of a writer. If you trackback, you might find that everyone who has been tagged has dealt with this their own way. I will try to keep it simple and unpretentious, just like the girl-next-door you wished you lived next door to.

A good writer.

Fits you like a sock.
The first few lines. It's all in the first few lines. If it starts good, it probably is all the way. And the metaphoric advice isn't silly. Try it. Pull up a sock to your ankle and it fits you well you just have to pull it up all the way. It's karmic engineering (or plain good elastic). That's how I picked up most of my books that now take up more space in my house than the floor.

Wants you to enjoy his creation. Which is why he keeps it simple. No complicated 233 word sentences. Or a fiery volley of words that leave you with a weight upon thy tongue (apologies to the great bard). Their words are their arsenal. But not big, flashy ones. They would rather employ small, sharp knives that seldom inspire awe or fear, but cut red and deep. And the pain is scarlet. To illustrate with an example; Haruki Murakami in 'Hard Boiled Wonderland and the End of The World, describes Dylan's voice as, "Like a kid standing at the window watching the rain". Feel that? Good. Next.

Is interesting. There's a plot. And it moves. The writer has a point of view. An idea, a theory, a concept. And he wants to share it. He wants to be heard. And the one's who succeed in talking to us, are the ones who kept them interesting. And this holds true from the very first time man learnt to write. They were stories with epic battles, brave men who fought dragons, rough seas and beautiful women who liked marmalade. All an attempt to keep us reading. And it worked. Still does.

Lets us find the magic. He seldom tries too hard. A regular slight of hand becomes fantastic, ethereal even. And it is done amidst the casual clutter of everyday. Do you remember feeling hungry while reading about the Famous Five? Or feel despair like the Joads? Didn't you feel like making aquiantance with a certain Bertram Wooster as he slipped into the Drones for dinner? You remember the littlest of details, the most insignificant ones that have nothing to do with the plot. Because one lazy afternoon, a long, long time ago, as you were reading in bed, you guffawed out loud or wet the pillow case with uncontrollable, little sobs. All for a few words, carefully and lovingly arranged for you to feel that way.

Respects you. There is a breed of writers, who write to assert their superiority. Their godlike grasp over the subtle nuances of the language. Their skills in weaving 3,076 characters in one episode. Their ability to manufacture fantasy characters with semi-Gaelic first names. It shows a clear lack of things to say. They aren't storytellers, or communicators, or propogators of change. They are there to fill up shelves of yellowish, chain, neon-lit, plasticky book stores.

Can induce change. That's because he makes you think. His idea is something that you spend time with, long after you have finished reading what he had to write. You argue with people over fictional characters you feel compelled to like or dislike. You are scared to admit that they scare you. That's how they bring about change. In acceptability. In society. In morality. Future states of being. There are enough examples to go around without me indulging in name dropping. And those of you who have reached this far are probably rattling off a thousand examples in their head as you read this line. Well, didn't you?

There are more things. Bigger, greater, more important things that a writer does to amass the kind of strength that he has. To move generations by a sweep of the pen. But these are the few things that I thought are the most important. That what gives a writer the keys to our kingdom. To enter our being and flutter there forever. Becoming who we are, almost.

I have to stop. Thanks again Atul for doing this. I am on holiday, but this was simply too tempting to give it a pass. Besides, it helped break my deadlock for the past ten odd days. Before I go, I need to tag people who will give it the respect it deserves. And here they are, in no specific order.

devil mood | delivered
kapitan niemand
tangled up in views
d h roark |
delivered
crazybawa | delivered

I don't know how you guys will react to this on a musty Monday morning. But I am sure you guys will take this forward. In your own little quirky ways.

Topped with extra mayo.

Cartoon courtesy The Far Side by Gary Larson. Those of you who don't know him, die.

25 comments:

Anonymous said...

i wouldn't have expected anything less. You are judge dredd when it comes to doing tags. bewarned, henceafter!

i am in the middle of a post, trying hard to make meaning about a thought and -- ding -- your comment is delivered. you talking of pressure? man - i gotta rewrite my post (i'll have-to-have-to change two words!!!)

thanks for taking this up - hope your holiday is much more fun. truly deeply mean it and such.

Am just just adding a few lettuce leaves underneath the mayo and sneaking in a few croutons!

am lovin' it!

phish said...

the holiday IS fun. and i am only glad to be doing this. surprised at your quick appraisal of the same. but glad you liked it.

and i seriously dont think you need to change yours at all. but i be finicky about the croutons meself.

Devil Mood said...

Did you write this in the morning or yesterday night? I couldn't possibly write so coherently in the morning haha

good writer = phish :)

Thanks for tagging me, I feel flattered. It'll be hard doing this without being influenced by what you wrote because it looks like you really thought this through. But I'll try! And, yes, I did feel extremely hungry reading the famous Five :)

Devil Mood said...

I'm going to kill you hahaha!
I followed the link - I can't believe wikipedia has an article on that, how morbid!

phish said...

devil mood - i wrote in the last three odd hours. it's actually monday morning 2 am, where i am. and i am sure you will be just as good.

the wiki article is a riot though. its quite earnest and thats what's funny.

would you believe, i still haven't come across a scone, ever.

Anonymous said...

hm, you yourself should write more often, phish, for the benefit of your readers.

I disagree with this, however. For example, Anna Karenina has one of the most memorable openings of all time:
("All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way."
But it's full of sentences with 233 words. And it's a fantastic book...or is it? I guess someone would disagree with me, LOL!

Goldbug said...

i love the piece and hate the pressure it brings! sigh.
by the way.. where in time are u?

phish said...

chrispito - ummm. i agree it is not just a fantastic book but also an exception, not too many can ramble and still be dramatic. 'atlas shrugged', the radio commentary comes to mind. also heller's 'good as gold' can fall into this category.

and i am glad you enjoyed this.


dhroark - this is right up your alley. i can almost see the gleam in the blue corner of your little left eye...

Bhaskar Khaund said...

Phish , very good blog.
Now i draw the sheath(small).
:-)

Devil Mood said...

Neither have I! My mother has the recipe for scones but she hasn't done them while I was in this world, as far as I know...

meraj said...

once again, great stuff phish...and this time an acacemic one too.

thanks and cheers!
m

scribbleamus said...

nice. but do you know when you got too much toothpaste on your brush?

phish said...

bhaskar - yes, your small sheath just might be enough here :)

devil: ah. i downloaded it as well. one of these days.

meraj: thanks m. but its yourturn to take it forward now.

scribbelamus: always. but i just put it in my mouth anyways.

madelyn said...

I love the magic - the slight of
hand - and feeling -
truly - that the writer like you.

Well done:)

Smiling Dolphin said...

excellent post. now you need to do a similar one on photographers. happy halloween as they say out here, lynn

Ash said...

Nice post. I enjoyed reading this!

didactylos said...

light, engaging, true and demonstrative of the qualities spoken.

i enjoyed reading this.

and excellent far side choice. tho anything by gary larson is excellent axiomatically.

phish said...

maddie - thank you. just back from a vacation and health is taking a beating still. but promise to be regular soon. i am gald u enjoyed this.

smiling dolphin - that's an idea. hmmm. happy halloween to you too.

ash - ah. you are most kind.

didactylos - a fellow far side lover. couldn't agree more my friend.

Anonymous said...

So much I never put any thought to. I realised, I have a certain responsibility when I started getting regular readership. But then again I don't consider myself much of a writer. This post helps differentiate a good writer from the other kinds. Made for a fantastic read.

dharmabum said...

oh thats a good one. i especially like the change bit, as i feel it strongly too. well written, my friend, neat!

PS: i did not know that garry fellow. i do now. do i still have to die? (i did follow the link on wiki, just for curiosity

Anonymous said...

Hoping you are well.

Looking forward to more words.

Miss Iyer said...

oooooo cardinal rules! Very well written Phish. I'm glad I blogrolled you. :)

phish said...

educatedunemployed - modesty will get you nowehere. everyone has a responsibility, esp. if people love what you write. we are all very busy remember :) and I am glad you liked this.

dharmabum - you should :) gary larson is, well, god. pick him up. send me your love letter afterwards.

videoxy - I plead guilty. laptop lcd screwed. dots and dashes. a small fortune. will be back, soon.

miss iyer - the feeling is mutual
;)

Gauri Gharpure said...

an extremely well written copy in itself... after i began reading this one, i realised i had read it before.. but ws even better reading the second time.. have u read orwell's rules of writing? they are also sheer common sense and very worthy of a read

phish said...

gauri - and i thank you again. no, i haven't read it but will surely pick it up once i head to a new book store. went back in time to read my own stuff again and the comments that followed. felt weird, somehow.